England vs India 2018: Who is to blame for the English debacle? 

England v India: Specsavers 3rd Test - Day One
Shikhar Dhawan nicking one to the slips

India lost, yet again in overseas conditions. One more opportunity to remove the tag of "lions at home" gone a-begging.

The fact that India could not beat an average English side, which is struggling to find world-class batsmen and who instead fields three to four all-rounders in its team, is going to hurt for a long time. This was a massive opportunity to win a series in England but it was not to be.

The Indian bowling has never looked so good. This pace quartet of Ishant Sharma, Mohammad Shami, Jasprit Bumrah and Umesh Yadav (with Bhuvaneshwar Kumar waiting in the wings as he was injured) has been a revelation in this series. They have been relentless, bowling over after over in the right areas. One can argue that almost every time they failed to dismiss the English lower middle order cheaply, but, it's not easy to run through sides on a recurring basis as there are bound to be some partnerships. In spite of those lower order partnerships, Indian bowlers didn't allow the English side to put big runs on the board.

It is time to find out what went wrong and who to blame for this loss. If India can find the chinks in their armour, then they can strive to take some corrective steps in the dead rubber (5th Test), which will start in a few days time.


#1 Opening batsmen

Batsmen let the Indian team down repeatedly in this series. Lord's was a disaster and the rest of the series was mediocre for everyone except Virat Kohli. India seriously needs to look beyond Shikhar Dhawan as an opener. Dhawan has failed to deliver in South Africa and England. His technique leaves a lot to be desired. Quick twenties and thirties are not good enough for Test cricket.

The Indian openers were sitting ducks throughout the series. There is another disaster which is waiting to happen in Australia if opening issues are not addressed. Mitchell Starc, Pat Cummins and Josh Hazelwood are much better bowlers than this English attack and they must be licking their lips, after looking at the performance of Indian openers in England. KL Rahul also needs to tighten up his game, otherwise, Australia might well turn out to be the last opportunity for him on the road of Test cricket.

#2 Rigid Selections

England v India: Specsavers 3rd Test - Day One
Hardik Pandya getting out to Anderson

Rigid selections are another reason that cost India dearly. Indian team seems to be obsessed with this idea of having an all-rounder in the team. Hardik Pandya has played close to 7 matches in overseas conditions just on the basis of his potential as an all-rounder. His potential is not turning into performance, barring few occasions like his 5-wicket haul at Trent Bridge. To be an all-rounder he needs to deliver with the bat but he has failed consistently. Moreover, whenever he comes to the crease his stint doesn't inspire any sort of confidence that he can handle good bowling on lively wickets. In the obsession to play an all-rounder, the Indian team failed to strengthen their struggling batting line-up. It would have been much wiser to play an extra batsman in place of a struggling all-rounder.

The selection of Kuldeep Yadav at Lord's was another mind-boggling decision, especially after the rain-delayed start. Playing an extra spinner under overcast conditions in England is never a good idea.

Another series lost, another opportunity gone. This is the time to introspect and to admit the mistakes. Once you admit your mistakes, you are halfway there on the path to recovery and with Australia beckoning, that recovery needs to be fast and quick.

Brand-new app in a brand-new avatar! Download CricRocket for fast cricket scores, rocket flicks, super notifications and much more! 🚀☄️

Quick Links